By - Jeremiah Grant
Last Updated - July 22nd, 2024 9:30 AM
Jul 22
Did you know that the cafe industry in the United States is experiencing significant growth, with over 35,000 establishments nationwide? Understanding its true value is crucial if you’re considering buying or selling a cafe. This blog will guide you through the key elements affecting cafe valuation, such as location, revenue, and operational efficiency. You’ll also learn about valuation methods like Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) and market multiples, ensuring you make informed decisions in this thriving market.
The cafe industry has shown remarkable resilience and growth despite the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. In the U.S., the market reached anannual revenue of $80 billion in 2023, with over 60% of Americans consuming coffee daily. The number of branded coffee shops hasgrown by 2.4% since pre-pandemic times.
Globally, the coffee market is projected to grow from $223.1 billion in 2023 to$290.2 billion by 2030, at a CAGR of 5.4%. This growth is driven by increasing urbanization, rising disposable incomes, and a cultural shift towards coffee consumption. Specialty coffee, such as single-origin and artisanal blends, is particularly popular, attracting a discerning customer base.
Despite the positive trends, the industry faces challenges like high operational costs and staffing shortages. However, innovations in technology, such as online ordering and pre-ordering, have helped cafes adapt and thrive. Franchise models are also becoming more popular, helping operators manage expansion risks.
With such robust growth and evolving dynamics, accurately valuing a cafe becomes more critical than ever. Let’s understand how to value a cafe.
Know the Real Value of Your Cafe Today!
Gain insights for growth strategies, investment decisions, or preparing for a successful sale with our specialized coffee shop valuation services.
The first step in valuing a cafe for sale is to calculate the Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE). SDE represents the true profit of the business by adjusting the financial statements to reflect the owner’s benefits and discretionary expenses. Here’s how to calculate it:
1. Analyzing Financial Statements and Tax Returns:
Start by examining the cafe’s financial documents, including the income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow statement. Additionally, review the business’s tax returns to gain comprehensive insights into its financial health and any tax-related adjustments.
2. Adjusting for Owner Compensation and Discretionary Expenses:
Adjust the financials to account for the owner’s compensation and any discretionary expenses that are not essential to the operation of the business. These may include personal expenses, non-recurring expenses, and any other costs that a new owner would not incur. The goal is to normalize the earnings to reflect the true operating profit for a potential buyer.
3. Calculating the SDE:
After making the necessary adjustments, sum up the adjusted earnings to determine the SDE. This figure is crucial for assessing the cafe’s profitability and attractiveness to buyers.
Next, determine the appropriate multiple to apply to the SDE. This multiple reflects various factors such as the cafe’s financial performance, growth potential, and market conditions.
4. Determining the Appropriate Multiple:
Market multiples for cafes typically range from 1.5 to 2.5. Several factors influence the selection of the appropriate multiple, including revenue, the type of cafe, owner involvement, and family roles.
Revenue and Type of Cafe: Cafes with higher revenue and a strong customer base may command a higher multiple. Specialty coffee shops or those with unique offerings might also receive a higher valuation.
Owner Involvement: The level of the owner’s involvement in daily operations affects the multiple. Cafes that can operate independently of the owner are generally more valuable.
Family Roles: The extent to which family members are involved in the business can impact the valuation. Independent management structures are typically seen as more stable.
By combining the SDE with the appropriate multiple, you can arrive at a fair market value for the cafe.
Additional Factors to Consider When Valuing a Cafe
When valuing a cafe for sale, consider several factors beyond just the seller’s earnings and a basic multiple. Key elements such as equipment quality, licenses, lease terms, and employee verification significantly influence the cafe’s overall value.
1. Evaluating Equipment Quality and Liquor Licenses:
Equipment Quality: List and value all the cafe’s equipment. Consider the original cost, depreciation, and current market value. High-quality, well-maintained equipment reduces the need for immediate capital investment and enhances the cafe’s appeal to buyers.
Liquor Licenses: In states with strict alcohol laws, a liquor license can significantly increase the café’s value by offering additional revenue streams. Assess the cost and transferability of the license to understand its impact on the overall valuation.
2. Assessing Lease Terms and Employee Verification:
Lease Terms: Long-term or transferable leases add substantial value by providing stability and avoiding future rent negotiations. Review the terms of the current lease to determine its impact on the cafe’s valuation.
Employee Verification: Having a verified, well-documented workforce indicates stability and good management practices. Buyers often place higher value on businesses with reliable and transparent employee records.
By thoroughly evaluating the cafe’s equipment, licenses, lease terms, and employee documentation, in conjunction with the seller’s earnings and valuation multiple, you can obtain a comprehensive understanding of its market value.
Factors That Drive Up the Value
Valuing a cafe for sale involves looking at several key factors. These factors make the cafe more appealing to buyers. This can lead to a higher valuation.
One major factor is how much the owner is involved. Cafes that can run well with little owner input are usually more valuable. This shows they can grow and attract buyers who prefer to step back.
Another key factor is if the owner’s family is not too involved. Cafes where family and business are separate are more appealing. This avoids the issues that come with family business conflicts.
High-quality, well-maintained equipment boosts a cafe’s value. It shows the cafe is a smart investment and doesn’t need much new money.
A liquor license adds value by offering more ways to make money. It makes the cafe more appealing.
Having detailed records on employees shows the cafe is stable and well-run. This can increase its value.
By focusing on these areas, cafe owners can make their business more appealing to buyers. These factors are key to increasing cafe value and cafe valuation drivers. They are important when selling a cafe.
I recently undertook a detailed valuation for a bustling cafe located in downtown Seattle, Washington. This cafe, known for its artisanal coffee and minimal owner involvement, presented an excellent opportunity to showcase a step-by-step approach to determining its fair market value.
Step 1: Gathering Financial Data
Financial Statements:
Income Statement: The cafe’s income statement showed annual revenues of $1,200,000 and net profits of $180,000.
Balance Sheet: The cafe had total assets valued at $400,000 and liabilities of $120,000.
Cash Flow Statement: The cash flow statement indicated consistent positive cash flows with net cash flow from operations at $200,000.
Tax Returns:
The past three years of tax returns were reviewed to ensure consistency and accuracy of reported income and expenses.
Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) is a crucial metric in valuing small businesses like cafés. It represents the total financial benefit an owner derives from the business.
Adjustments:
Owner’s Salary: The owner’s annual salary of $60,000 was added back to the net profit.
Personal Expenses: Personal expenses totaling $15,000 (such as travel and non-essential office supplies) were also added back.
One-Time Expenses: A one-time repair expense of $10,000 was added back as it would not be a recurring cost for the new owner.
SDE Calculation:
Net Profit: $180,000
Owner’s Salary: $60,000
Personal Expenses: $15,000
One-Time Expenses: $10,000
Total SDE: $265,000
Step 3: Determining the Appropriate Multiple
The valuation multiple for cafés typically ranges from 1.5 to 2.5, influenced by factors such as location, revenue consistency, growth potential, and operational efficiency.
Factors Considered:
Location: The cafe’s prime downtown location in a high-traffic area justified a higher multiple.
Revenue Consistency: Consistent year-over-year revenue growth and stable profit margins.
Operational Efficiency: Minimal owner involvement with a reliable management team in place.
Market Conditions: Favorable market conditions for coffee shops in Seattle, known for its coffee culture.
Selected Multiple: Based on these factors, a multiple of 2.3 was deemed appropriate.
Step 4: Applying the Multiple to SDE
Valuation Calculation:
SDE: $265,000
Multiple: 2.3
=> Estimated Value: $265,000 x 2.3 = $609,500
Step 5: Assessing Additional Factors
Equipment and Fixtures:
The cafe’s high-quality equipment, including espresso machines and kitchen appliances, were in excellent condition, adding approximately $30,000 in value.
Lease Terms:
The café had a long-term, transferable lease with favorable terms, adding stability and increasing its attractiveness to potential buyers.
Intangible Assets:
The cafe’s strong brand reputation and loyal customer base were considered significant intangible assets, estimated to add another $25,000 to the valuation.
After considering all the adjustments and additional factors, the final valuation of the cafe was calculated as follows:
Base Valuation (SDE x Multiple): $609,500
+ Equipment Value: $30,000
+ Intangible Assets: $25,000
Total Estimated Value: $664,500
You see, valuing a cafe involves a comprehensive analysis of financial performance, operational factors, and market conditions. I arrived at a robust and fair market value for this cafe in downtown Seattle by using current, up-to-date methods and multiples and factoring in both the tangible and intangible value. This was just one example. I have plenty of client examples to share and explain that will make you understand how your cafe should be valued.
Know the Real Value of Your Cafe Today!
Gain insights for growth strategies, investment decisions, or preparing for a successful sale with our specialized coffee shop valuation services.
To enhance your cafe’s value and attract potential buyers, consider these actionable tips:
Build a Reliable Management Team: A well-trained and dependable management team can operate the cafe independently, making it more attractive to buyers seeking a passive investment.
Maintain High-Quality Equipment: Regularly service and upgrade your equipment to ensure it remains in excellent condition. High-quality equipment reduces the need for immediate capital investment and adds value.
Secure Favorable Lease Terms: Negotiate long-term, transferable leases to provide stability and avoid future rent increases. Favorable lease terms can significantly enhance your cafe’s market value.
Keep Detailed Employee Records: Maintain accurate and up-to-date records of all employees. Transparent and verified employee documentation indicates good management practices and stability.
Diversify Revenue Streams: Consider obtaining a liquor license or offering unique products like specialty coffee blends to diversify and increase revenue. Additional revenue streams make your cafe more appealing to potential buyers.
By implementing these strategies, you can strategically enhance your cafe’s value and ensure a successful sale.
Conclusion
Valuing a cafe for sale is a detailed process. It looks at the business’s finances, assets, and more. Knowing why you’re valuing it helps. Then, you calculate the Seller’s Discretionary Earnings and pick the right multiple. Finally, consider factors that affect the value to find a fair market price.
When valuing a cafe, think about its potential revenue, the use of local ingredients, competition, and customer loyalty. Using the income, market, and asset approaches gives a full view of your cafe’s value.
If you’re looking to buy or sell a cafe, partnering with seasoned experts can make all the difference. With over 20 years of practical experience, I’m a dual-certified business appraiser (CVA, CLCS) renowned for my expertise in business valuation and economic damages. Additionally, my company boasts a team with over 200 years of combined experience drawn from top accountancy firms and Fortune 500 companies, ensuring we provide reliable, detailed, and professional valuation services.
Why Choose Us?
Extensive Expertise: Over two decades of experience in business valuation alone.
Proven Track Record: Comprehensive experience across diverse industries, including the cafe sector.
Detailed Analysis: An in-depth and well-explained approach is used to ensure accurate and defensible valuations.
Reach out to us to ensure you receive the best valuation for your cafe, helping you make well-informed, strategic decisions.
Jeremiah Grant
Jeremiah Grant is the Managing Partner of Arrowfish Consulting. In addition to acting as a primary liaison for many of the firm’s engagements, He primarily focuses on business valuation and economic damages expert witness assignments, in addition to forensic accounting and insurance claims analysis.
Discover how to value a travel agency valuation accurately. Learn key factors, methods, and expert tips to determine your agency's worth in today's market.
Getting the right valuation for your agency is key for you to make a successful exit, if you ever need to. To find a property’s true value, you need to look at things like net operating income (NOI) and the capitalization rate. This guide will cover the basics of real estate agency valuation. It will […]
