As an insurance agency owner, knowing your business’s value is key. You might be thinking of selling, buying another agency, or passing it down. The value isn’t just about how big your client list is. It’s about many things working together.

Learning how to value your agency well helps you make smart choices. It also helps you get the most out of your investment.

Many things affect an insurance agency’s value. These include its financial health, how well it runs, where it stands in the market, and its potential for growth. By understanding these factors, you can see how valuable your agency really is. This knowledge puts you in a strong position in the industry.

A detailed valuation sheds light on how your agency is doing. This helps you spot areas to improve and plan better strategies. It’s super useful for the benefits of valuing insurance agencies and getting ready for changes in ownership.

A Little About the Industry

The insurance industry is a significant global market, valued at approximately USD 6.2 trillion in 2023, with the fastest growth rate of 7.5% since 2006. The United States remains a dominant player, contributing 44.2% of the global market share. The sector includes life, property and casualty (P&C), and health insurance, with life insurance growing by 8.4%, P&C by 7.0%, and health insurance by 6.6% in 2023​​​.

In 2022, the U.S. insurance industry’s net premiums written totaled $1.4 trillion. The industry employs over 2.8 million people across the country​. The property insurance sector in North America is projected to exceed $300 billion by 2025. Despite global economic uncertainties, merger and acquisition (M&A) activities in the insurance sector reached a decade-high of 449 deals in 2022, driven by strategic expansions into emerging markets, particularly in Asia-Pacific​.

The insurance market is also adapting to technological advancements, with significant investments in digital transformation, AI, and cybersecurity to improve operational efficiency and customer experience​.

Know Your Insurance Agency’s
Worth Today!

Gain strategic insights for expansion, mergers, or acquisitions with our specialized insurance agency valuation services.

Book A free Consultation

What is the Basis of Valuation in Insurance?

Valuing an insurance agency is more than just looking at the book of business. Many factors play a role in determining its worth. These include the agency’s size, location, growth, and profits. The quality and diversity of clients also matter.

The types of products sold, the agency’s reputation, and its market position are important too. So are the strength of the staff and the efficiency of the operations. Even potential risks and opportunities are considered.

Live Oak Bank says insurance agencies are usually worth 2x-3x their revenue or 6x-9x their EBITDA. This shows how crucial being profitable is for an agency’s value, much like how thorough assessments are necessary in related fields such as business interruption claims.

The final value of an insurance agency comes from looking at its finances, how well it runs, and its potential for growth. These factors help determine its worth to potential buyers.

How to Value an Insurance Book of Business

Valuing an insurance agency starts with understanding the insurance book of business. There are two main ways to figure out its worth: the revenue multiplier method and the EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization) multiplier method.

Revenue Multiplier Method

This method multiplies the total annual revenue by a certain percentage. The percentage changes based on the insurance types, customer keep rates, and the book’s size. A bigger book with valuable policies and strong customer loyalty gets a higher multiplier.

EBITDA Multiplier Method

This method uses a multiplier based on the agency’s cash flow. First, add up the agency’s net profit, interest, depreciation, amortization, taxes, owner’s pay, and any one-time costs. Then, multiply this EBITDA by a set number to find the book’s value.

Both methods are common in the insurance world for valuing an agency’s book. The choice between them depends on the book’s size, complexity, and the buyer’s needs and market trends.

Other Aspects Buyers Consider

When looking at an insurance agency’s value, buyers don’t just focus on the book of business. They look at how the agency grows on its own. They want to see it can bring in new customers, keep clients happy, and get referrals.

Buyers also check the agency’s reputation, leadership, and employees’ skills. They look for a strong brand, a steady management team, and a skilled and dedicated workforce. The agency’s tech setup and how well it runs are key, too. Buyers want to make sure the agency can serve clients well and grow.

Buyers also look at how well the agency keeps its clients, the variety of its clients, and the risks it takes. They like agencies with a mix of clients, few clients not to rely too much on any one, and a track record of keeping clients. The agency’s growth in revenue and profits is very important to buyers.

By looking at these different parts of an insurance agency, buyers get a full picture of its value and potential for success. This way, the price paid reflects the agency’s true worth and its ability to bring value to the new owner over time.

Understanding EBITDA for Insurance Agencies

EBITDA stands for Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization. It’s a key way to measure an insurance agency’s profit. This method removes costs linked to running the business. The value of EBITDA for insurance agencies varies based on several factors.

These include the agency’s size, growth, and profits. Also, the types of products sold and how efficiently the agency operates matter.

What is a Good EBITDA Multiple?

Smaller insurance agencies usually sell for 4 to 6 times their EBITDA. Larger agencies, with over $1 million in EBITDA, can go for 5 to 8 times. But, the market is now seeing higher valuations, up to 8 to 9 times EBITDA.

Earn-outs over 2-3 years help achieve higher valuations. This is done through growth targets and certain conditions. Buyers look for synergies from acquisitions not shown in the financials to support higher valuations.

Private-equity backed brokers aim to increase their valuations yearly. They use rapid growth and recapitalization every 4-6 years to do this.

It’s important to keep an eye on EBITDA and compare it to similar agencies. Consider how various aspects like financial performance impact your agency’s valuation, similar to how medical practice evaluations are approached. A 30-40% EBITDA might suggest the agency isn’t investing enough for growth. On the other hand, a high EBITDA compared to others could mean issues with staffing or costs.

The average EBITDA multiple is a good guide, but an agency’s true value can change. It depends on its size, profits, clients, and growth potential. An experienced M&A advisor can help owners get a fair price for their agency.

Methods to Value an Insurance Agency

Market Approach

Valuing an insurance agency using the market approach involves comparing the target agency with similar businesses that have recently been sold. This method is grounded in real-world data and reflects what buyers are currently willing to pay for similar entities. The market approach is advantageous because it is straightforward and relies on observable market transactions, making it a practical choice for many appraisers and business owners.

Methods within the Market Approach:

1. Mergers and Acquisitions Method: This method looks at the sale prices of recently acquired comparable insurance agencies. By analyzing these transactions, one can infer the market’s valuation standards and trends. For instance, if a comparable insurance agency was sold for $3 million and another for $3.2 million, the target agency can be evaluated within that price range, considering its unique attributes.
2. Guideline Public Company Method: This method involves using financial data from publicly traded insurance companies. Although these companies may operate on a larger scale, their financial ratios and performance metrics provide valuable benchmarks. For example, if a public company trades at a price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) of 15, a private agency might be valued similarly after adjusting for differences in size and market presence.

Pros and Cons:

• Pros:
  • Simplicity and Understandability: The market approach is easy to comprehend and apply, even for those without extensive financial expertise.
  • Reliability: It relies on actual market transactions rather than projections, which can be speculative.
• Cons:
  • Data Availability: Finding comparable sales data can be challenging, as many transactions are private and not publicly disclosed.
  • Market Fluctuations: The value derived from this approach can be influenced by economic conditions and regulatory changes, making it less stable in volatile markets.

Example Application: Consider an insurance agency specializing in auto insurance. If similar agencies in the same geographic region have sold for multiples of their annual commissions (e.g., 1.5 times their annual commissions), this metric can be used to estimate the value of the target agency. If the target agency earns $2 million in annual commissions, its estimated value might be around $3 million.

By leveraging the market approach, agency owners can obtain a realistic and market-aligned valuation, aiding in negotiations and strategic decisions​.

Income Approach

The income approach is a widely used method for valuing insurance agencies, focusing on the business’s ability to generate future earnings. This approach is particularly insightful as it considers both the risk and growth potential of the agency.

Methods within the Income Approach:

1. Capitalized Earnings Method: This method begins with the agency’s annual earnings, which are then capitalized using a market-derived capitalization rate. The capitalization rate reflects the required rate of return by investors, adjusted for the risk associated with the agency. For instance, if an agency has annual earnings of $500,000 and a capitalization rate of 10%, its valuation would be $5 million.
2. Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method: The DCF method involves projecting the agency’s future earnings over a specific period, typically 3-5 years, and then discounting these earnings back to their present value using a discount rate. This rate often includes a risk premium. For example, if an agency projects $1 million in earnings annually for the next five years, and the discount rate is 12%, the present value of these earnings would provide the agency’s valuation.

Pros and Cons:

• Pros:
  • Detailed Future Outlook: This approach provides a comprehensive view of the agency’s future earnings potential, which is particularly useful for growing businesses.
  • Risk Assessment: By incorporating discount rates, it effectively accounts for the risks associated with the agency’s operations.
• Cons:
  • Complexity: Requires detailed financial projections and a thorough understanding of financial modeling.
  • Speculative: Relies heavily on future projections, which can be uncertain and subject to change.

Example Application: For an insurance agency with a strong client base and consistent revenue growth, the DCF method might be particularly appropriate. Suppose this agency projects to earn $2 million, $2.2 million, and $2.4 million over the next three years, respectively, with a discount rate of 10%. The present value of these earnings would provide a clear picture of its current value.

The income approach is invaluable for providing a nuanced understanding of an agency’s financial health and future prospects, making it a cornerstone method in the valuation process​

Asset-Based Approach

The asset-based approach determines the value of an insurance agency by evaluating its assets and subtracting its liabilities. Although this method is less commonly used in the insurance industry compared to the market and income approaches, it can still provide valuable insights, especially in specific scenarios like liquidation or restructuring.

Methods within the Asset-Based Approach:

1. Adjusted Net Asset Value Method: This method starts by listing all the agency’s assets and liabilities at their book value. The assets are then adjusted to reflect their current market value. This adjustment can include both tangible assets, like office equipment and real estate, and intangible assets, such as customer relationships and brand value. For example, if an agency owns a building valued at $500,000 but it has appreciated to $600,000, this higher value is used in the calculation.
2. Book Value Method: This straightforward method uses the values recorded in the agency’s balance sheet without adjustments. It’s most accurate immediately after a transaction when the recorded values are most likely to represent fair market value. For instance, if the balance sheet lists total assets at $2 million and total liabilities at $1 million, the agency’s book value would be $1 million.

Pros and Cons:

• Pros:
  • Simplicity: Especially with the book value method, it’s easy to calculate and understand.
  • Objective: Provides a clear, factual basis for valuation, particularly useful in liquidation scenarios.
• Cons:
  • Market Disconnect: May not accurately reflect the agency’s earning potential or market conditions.
  • Intangible Assets: Often undervalues intangible assets, which can be significant for an insurance agency.

Example Application: Consider an insurance agency with the following balance sheet:

• Assets:
  • Real Estate: $800,000 (market value $1,000,000)
  • Office Equipment: $50,000 (market value $40,000)
  • Accounts Receivable: $200,000
  • Intangible Assets (Customer Relationships): $300,000 (market value $500,000)
• Liabilities:
  • Loans: $400,000
  • Accounts Payable: $150,000

Using the adjusted net asset value method, the total adjusted assets would be $1,740,000 (real estate $1,000,000 + office equipment $40,000 + accounts receivable $200,000 + intangible assets $500,000). Subtracting the liabilities ($550,000) gives an adjusted net asset value of $1,190,000.

This approach can be particularly useful for potential buyers looking to assess the liquidation value or for agencies in financial distress needing an accurate assessment of their worth

Increasing Your Agency’s Value

As an insurance agency owner, making your business more valuable is key. This is true whether you’re selling it or passing it down. By using smart strategies, you can make your agency worth more. Let’s look at ways to increase insurance agency value and strategies to maximize insurance agency value.

One good way is to keep your clients happy. Building strong bonds with them and offering great service can lead to more renewals. This makes your agency more valuable. Making it easy for new clients to join and keeping in touch with them can also keep them coming back.

Creating a strong referral system is also smart. Getting your happy clients to tell others about you can bring in new customers. Offering rewards for referrals can make them even more eager to share the word.

Having a strong online presence is also key. A modern website and active social media can help you reach more people. This shows off your expertise and makes your agency more attractive to buyers.

Using a mix of keeping clients, getting referrals, and online marketing can really boost your agency’s value. By following these ways to increase insurance agency value and strategies to maximize insurance agency value, you set your business up for growth. This prepares it for a smooth sale or transfer if needed.

Key Considerations and Risks

Valuing an insurance agency is complex and requires careful evaluation. It’s important to know the risks and limitations of different valuation methods. Knowing what to consider and the risks can help you make better decisions and get a more accurate agency value.

Looking at your agency’s financial performance is key. Revenue, profitability, and EBITDA are crucial for agency value. Understanding your agency’s financial history and market trends is essential for a fair valuation.

Also, think about your client base. A diverse and stable client base can increase your agency’s value. Agencies with a wide range of clients and strong client loyalty are more appealing to buyers.

The insurance industry’s rules can also pose risks. Agencies must follow many rules, including licensing, data privacy, and cybersecurity. Working with M&A advisors and valuation experts can help you deal with these issues and prepare for a sale.

Market conditions outside your agency can affect its value too. Keep up with industry trends, economic factors, and competition. This knowledge can help you understand how your agency’s value might change.

Understanding the factors and risks in valuing an insurance agency helps you tackle challenges. It ensures a more accurate and favorable valuation. For instance, addressing potential fraud issues can be as critical as evaluating your client base and financial performance. Working with experts can also help you navigate the valuation process and boost your agency’s value.

Know Your Insurance Agency’s
Worth Today!

Gain strategic insights for expansion, mergers, or acquisitions with our specialized insurance agency valuation services.

Book A free Consultation

Conclusion

Knowing the value of your insurance agency is crucial for informed decision-making, whether you’re planning to sell, expand, or strategize for the future. This involves analyzing various factors such as financial health, client base, and market positioning. It’s similar to how issues like falsifying FMLA paperwork can impact business evaluations.

At Arrowfish Consulting, we provide detailed and precise valuation services. With over two decades of experience, I, Jeremiah Grant, bring deep expertise to ensure your agency’s worth is accurately determined. Our aim is to offer actionable insights that guide your business toward growth and success.

For expert guidance on valuing your insurance agency, contact us and we’d be happy to offer a free consultation to see how we can help.

Jeremiah Grant

Jeremiah Grant is the Managing Partner of Arrowfish Consulting. In addition to acting as a primary liaison for many of the firm’s engagements, He primarily focuses on business valuation and economic damages expert witness assignments, in addition to forensic accounting and insurance claims analysis.

•